Wednesday, April 30, 2008

troubles with tenses

TPM: Bush criminal administrator of the GSA invokes the Hortatory Subjunctive Defense:

Lurita Doan explained her grammatical shortfalls in her testimony today. But Democrats on the committee had a hard time buying it. Rep. John Yarmuth (D-KY) took her to task on her tense mincing over a statement Doan made about GSA employees that had cooperated with the Office of Special Council in its investigation into her conduct. When pushed, Doan claimed she meant to invoke the "hortatory subjuctive" when she said:

Until extensive rehabilitation of their performance occurs, they will not be getting promoted and will not be getting bonuses or special awards or anything of that nature.

Son of a Latin teacher, Rep. John Sarbanes (D-MD) disagreed. He called her statement the common "future" tense. He also spotted a connection between her grammatical defense and an accusation that she encouraged her employees to help out Republican Congressional races. At a presentation given by Karl Roves' deputy she asked her GSA employess: "How can we help our candidates?"

Includes video.

Hortatory subjunctive: a statement urging self and others to some action. Will always be in first person plural of subjunctive mood -- so in this case would be "Let us not promote them or give bonuses... " I fail to see how that's any better, even were it true.

Oh yeah -- the most important part is: she regrets nothing.

No comments: